Millions of dog owners choose a hotel on the strength of a pet friendly award, and none of the major schemes checks what it is ranking. This paper takes the winners of the two most visible awards, TripAdvisor's Travelers' Choice Best of the Best Pet Friendly Hotels and USA Today's 10Best Readers' Choice Best Pet Friendly Hotel, in every edition from 2024 to 2026, and sets them against the Roch Dog Friendly Standard, the published standard against which more than 3,000 hotels in 56 countries have been graded A+ to F.
The pattern has not changed in three years. The hotel TripAdvisor named the best pet friendly hotel in the world for 2025 publishes no pet policy on its own website, and the booking platforms that list it cannot agree whether its weight limit is 5 kilograms or 10 pounds. Twelve of that year's twenty winners had no public pet policy at all. The top of TripAdvisor's first American list grades D under our standard today, and in 2026 TripAdvisor published no pet friendly list at all. USA Today's 2026 readers' vote turns our grades almost exactly upside down: its number one grades C, its number two and four grade A, and its number six, where dogs of any size stay free, grades A+. The paper closes with the alternative that already exists, a published definition, a free grade from A+ to F that cannot be bought, and independent verification.